Food safety & sustainability: shifting to plant-rich diets
This is article two in a series by Dr Peter Emmrich on the changing landscape of food safety risk as a result of trends towards sustainability. Read article one on more sustainable production systems here.
Livestock uses 77% of agricultural land (for pasture and feed) and produces 66% agricultural GHG emissions from food production, but only provide 18% of global calories and 34% protein (not including aquatic foods) [FAOstat, 2019]. Shifting diets from away from animal-derived foods is crucial to meet the future demands in a finite world.
Animal products certainly have a role in sustainable food systems but as far as the Global North is concerned, that role must be smaller than it is now. Potentially more sustainable integrated and low-intensity livestock systems simply cannot produce the quantities of animal-based foods consumed in the Global North today.
Right now, consumption of animal-based products is rapidly increasing in middle-income countries, mostly driven by pig and chicken meat. Conversely, high-income countries are starting to see a reduction in consumption of animal-based products. This is mostly due to omnivores reducing their meat and dairy intake, rather than people turning entirely vegetarian or vegan.
Regarding what this implies for the food safety landscape, it is worth separating this into a shift away from animal-based products and a shift toward different kinds of non-animal-based products.
Animal-based foods contribute crucial nutrients, but also carry systemic risks
Animal products carry a wide range of food safety risks that could be reduced if they played a smaller role in the food system. These risks include meat, eggs or dairy carrying contamination with pathogenic microbes, contamination of both animal- and plant-products with manure, carcinogens associated with red and processed meat, antimicrobial resistance arising from livestock antimicrobial use and zoonotic disease risks like avian flu. Many of these risks cannot be controlled by food preparation alone, and contribute to the risk of future pandemics.
Animal products, of course, provide sources of essential nutrients, some of which such as “B12” and “omega-3” fatty acids are difficult or impossible to source from unprocessed plant-based foods. Some populations are also heavily dependent on these products for calcium, iron and protein. As populations adopt new foods, we must make sure that alternatives containing adequate levels of these nutrients are accessible to the relevant people, through a combination of fortification, formulation and consumer guidance.
Familiarity affects how hazards translate into risks
Now let’s consider the food safety concerns of the plant, algae and fermentation-based foods might replace meat. In their low-processed forms, these foods are typically already present in the food system and do not bring many new hazards with them – except toxicity and allergenicity risks from foods unfamiliar to a group of consumers. Legumes are a particular issue here as several of them carry natural toxins that can be dangerous when undercooked, as well as allergens and compounds that some consumers have to avoid (such as convicine in fava beans). As diets are change and communities are introduced to foods from other world regions, it is crucial that the cultural knowledge of how to prepare foods safely, travels with them.
More processed plant-based foods pose different challenges. Complex processing and many ingredients bring along challenges of hidden allergens such as lupins, soya, groundnuts, sesame. Often regulations (such as the UK’s Natasha’s Law, introduced in 2021) are already in place to track and highlight allergenicity risks but ongoing surveillance and clear labelling is needed to minimise these risks in unfamiliar food products with ingredients that are not immediately obvious to consumers.
New plant-based ingredients and formulations also bring along new contamination risks, e.g. mycotoxins, heavy metals and pesticides. This is a rapidly innovating field and most of the products on the shelf were developed a within the last few years. As a result, manufacturers, policymakers – and consumers – are still in a learning process of how to minimize food safety risks, especially those that creep in as production processes are scaled up and supply chains are streamlined to bring down prices, as the sector strives to reach price-parity with animal-based products.
New risks may emerge as novel products scale up
The innovation space is even larger when we look at the cell- and fermentation-based products. Most of this sector is yet earlier in the learning process and, despite headline-grabbing announcements, far from being price-competitive. Similarly to vertical farming, production of the highly controlled conditions is promised to allow for effective food safety surveillance.
But questions remain about the the nutritional value, contamination risk and risk of allergen feed-through from substrates in these new products – questions that cannot be fully answered until these products are produced at scale. Hence, we need critical evaluation of food safety and sustainability claims as these new companies scale up their production, to avoid getting locked into path dependency with new sustainability, safety or nutritional downsides.
Consumer knowledge remains crucial to food safety
Alongside all of these dietary shifts, we need to develop consumer knowledge about the real safety risks of new foods, as consumers might easily underestimate or overestimate risks associated with the unfamiliar. This also includes spoilage risks, where many of these new products are affected by the same risks as animal-based products, simply because they form a sufficiently similar growth medium for potentially harmful microorganisms.
The entry of new food products into the food systems requires vigilance from food safety experts to understand where new policy or consumer education is needed. We must take the opportunity now to engage with policymakers and the companies developing these new products to make foods that are both more sustainable and safer by design, and re-evaluate claims during scale-out, to avoid corners being cut that would endanger safety or sustainability.
In the third article in the series, we will cover how food safety risks are affected by efforts to reduce both food and plastic waste.
Dr Peter Emmrich
Share this article