What does net zero mean for the UK agri-food system?
The 2020s are a critically important decade if the world is to avoid catastrophic climate change. The IPCC stresses that we must have viable and effective mitigation strategies in place and working by the end of this decade.
Tackling climate change requires thinking about food, farming and land use. Globally, the agri-food system accounts for about a third of all emissions. In the UK, the agri-food system accounts for almost a quarter, just under half of which comes from agricultural production.
So, what needs to happen in the agri-food system for the UK to meet its net zero target by 2050?
Agri-food emissions and the UK
UK agricultural emissions are calculated to have fallen by around 15 per cent between 1990 and 2007. However, since then emissions appear to be flat-lining and more action is needed if the UK is to achieve its statutory commitment to net zero by 2050. Three priority areas for the agri-food system are
- Dietary change
- Land use change
- Changing farming practices
1. Dietary change
Sustainable diets are also usually healthier diets. In fact, if we all ate a balanced, healthy diet this would do more than enough to address greenhouse gas emissions. The challenge is that, as a population, too often we generally choose unhealthy diets.
Ruminant livestock farming and highly processed foods both have larger environmental impacts and contribute to unhealthy diets. Independent scientific opinion suggests that the UK needs at least a 20% reduction in the highest emitting foods by 2030 and a further 15% by 2050. This requires government action, but this poses a political problem.
The political attachment to free-markets and individual consumer preferences makes governments queasy about advising people on diets. Politicians fear accusations of nanny-statism, and the potential loss of voters.
2. Land use change
The UK’s national net zero by 2050 goal will require significant land use change. Most significant is the major expansion of forestry which current covers 3.2 million hectares or 13 % of the UK land area. By 2050, this is likely to need to have expanded to over 4 million hectares and to cover 19 to 20% of land.
The Government’s independent statutory advisor on Climate Change, the Climate Change Committee, recommends that planting rates need to almost treble to 30,000 hectares per year by 2025 and to ramp up even further in the 2030s.
The UK’s Carbon Budget also plans for an increase in land under energy crops grown to produce energy but also for carbon emissions to be captured and stored. Forestry and energy crops will mean less land available for conventional food production.
The UK Climate Change Committee estimates that there will be 23% less agricultural land by 2050 largely because of these other demands. Land pressures combine with diet pressures to suggest a reduction in livestock numbers, not only to reduce direct emissions, but also to free up land currently used to grow animal feedstuffs.
3. Changing farming practices
Achieving net zero in the UK will require changes to farming practices to reduce net emissions. The Government’s food strategy commits to maintaining current production levels to avoid the UK population becoming increasingly dependent upon imported food. So, the challenge is to produce at least the same amount of food from less land and with fewer emissions.
Debates about the future of farming and the environment tend to be dominated by two different ideas – “land-sparing” or “land-sharing”. Land-sparing approaches, sometimes called ‘sustainable intensification’ aim to increase the efficiency of production, allowing for production levels to be maintained but on a reduced land area, so freeing up land. These approaches often draw on technological advancements, such as improved crops and precision application of inputs.
Land-sharing approaches, on the other hand, aim to reduce the impact of farming by combining agricultural production with habitat restoration and carbon capture on the same land. Agroecology and agro-forestry are examples of land-sharing approaches.
Clearly there is overlap between these two approaches and it is likely that the two approaches could complement each other. A challenge here is the patchy evidence base to support how these systems might be most effectively encouraged. For example, how do we make sure that land-sparing approaches do indeed spare land or that carbon sequestration in soils represents a real, measurable benefit to net emissions?
In the UK, most practice change is likely to be focused around the three top sources of carbon emissions in agriculture. These are: ruminant farming and the management of slurry; fertiliser production and application, and; the use of fossil fuels for farm machinery and buildings.
In conclusion
The UK’s net zero target can seem daunting when it comes to the agri-food system. There are, however, some grounds for optimism.
The UK has been through agricultural transformations within living memory. The 1940s-70s era saw profound change, which was heavily shaped and influenced by government policy. The fact that the goals of net zero and improving public health are in alignment also gives some grounds for optimism.
It takes time, but governments and populations do adapt to evidence of public health risks. There have been some successes with regulatory-forcing measures such as the Sugar Levy, and laws to ban the sale of new petrol and diesel cars after 2030 show a willingness to regulate to accelerate system change.
Overall, the UK has less than a decade to enact the steps needed to prevent increasingly unmanageable climate change. Achieving this next transformation will depend upon a shared vision and the close working between private and public sector bodies across the agri-food system.
Author
Neil Ward is a Professor in the School of Environmental Sciences at UEA and is a member of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research and the Norwich Institute for Sustainable Development.
A human geographer by training, he has worked at University College London and the Universities of Leeds and Newcastle. He was seconded to the Cabinet Office to advise the last Labour Government on rural and agricultural policy and was Director of Newcastle University’s Centre for Rural Economy from 2004 to 2008.
Neil is a co-convenor of UKRI’s AgriFood4NetZero Network+, a £5m initiative to draw together scientists and social scientists with industry, stakeholders and policy-makers to support transformational change in the agri-food system to help meet the UK’s net zero by 2050 target.
Neil’s book, Net Zero, Food and Farming: Climate Change and the UK Agri-Food System, was published by Routledge in August.
Share this article