Nature Climate Change lists NISD Director’s paper amongst top in last decade
Professor Nitya Rao, Director of the NISD, has been listed as having one of the most important publications in Nature Climate Change in the decade it has existed. Previous Nature Climate Change Editor, Jenn Richler, cited Nitya’s article on women’s agency in response to climate change as an important step in the journal’s development.
Following this announcement, we interviewed Nitya to hear her reflections on the original article and the commendation from Nature Climate Change.
Congratulations Nitya! You’ve just been named as leading one of the stand-out articles in Nature Climate Change in the last decade of content. How does that feel and what are your thoughts when reflecting back on the article?
NR: As a social scientist it feels really great to be named as a standout article in a leading scientific journal such as Nature Climate Change.
One of the points that Jenn Richler makes is that social science is often very case specific. It draws valuable insights but that these findings are more difficult to generalise in terms of policy. In the same way, when producing these case studies across 25 climate hot spots in four different consortia working in three different agro-ecological zones, we wondered ‘how do we make the most sense of this?’ I must give credit to the funders (Canadian IDRC and DFID) in that they took gender seriously as a cross cutting issue and they supported meetings where we could specifically discuss these gender aspects.
We started thinking about consolidating our insights on gender in the context of climate adaptation in hot spots right from the very first year. This was critical in getting us accepted in Nature Climate Change and also for this recent acknowledgement. I believe we would not have got a social science article into Nature Climate Change if we had started thinking about publication at the end of the research, as is often the case.
In Jenn Richler’s comments, she mentions that your paper “marked an important expansion of social science content represented in the journal”. How do you feel about this comment and what made you choose to submit to Nature Climate Change at the time?
NR: When Jenn Richler mentions ‘expansion of social science content’ I believe she refers to it both conceptually and methodologically.
Conceptually, within the climate debate, women are often seen as victims or as overworked but we don’t really give any credit to women’s own agency or their ability to strategise. So we decided that women’s agency and adaptive capacity would be an important area to look at.
Methodologically, in our very first meeting as a cross-consortia gender research group, a training on gender concepts and methods at UEA, one of the participants suggested this methodology: ‘if you’re thinking about this qualitative research, you need to think of methods for comparing across the case studies in a more systematic way’.
At the time, Nature Climate Change wouldn’t have been a natural choice for me to publish as a social scientist. I attribute this publication decision to the proactive role of the donor in encouraging collaboration across themes and contexts (CARIAA). IDRC really emphasised the collaborative aspects of partnership, training and capacity building. Additionally, the donor’s interest in gender politics caused them to emphasise feminist and gender sensitive approaches. They set up a gender and equity group across consortia, combined this with a monitoring framework and they even gave us extra funding to meet when needed in order to write the article for Nature Climate Change.

Jenn’s article makes particular note of your choice of methodology; qualitative comparative analysis of case studies. What was it like working with this approach in pursuit of your research questions and what benefits does it offer?
NR: Although new to me at the time, qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) had been used by one of the team members. I had a good idea of the concepts and he helped us convert these concepts into indicators. The various case study authors had deep insights about their field sites, so ultimately this all came together.
The real benefit of QCA was that it raised issues which I was aware of but it forced me to think about exceptions and patterns. I worked in Southern Asia and Kenya for this project but QCA forced me to think about, ‘what are the patterns coming across different contexts and what can we say about these particular patterns. It forced you to think out of the box and out of one’s comfort zone in terms of explaining the reasons for these patterns.
Globally, there seems to be a focus on big data for research. QCA demonstrated that there are ways in which we could make qualitative work speak to the discourses around big data.
A final point is that globally, there seems to be a focus on big data for research. Everybody is looking for big data whether it is climate or food systems or otherwise. The organisations that have this big data are the ones who become influential. A big part of our motivation for experimenting with this QCA approach was to consider how we speak with qualitative work, which tends to be context specific, to the rise of big data. Qualitative researchers might sometimes feel like that their case studies are not really taken as seriously even though they are often very insightful and carry explanatory power. In this sense, QCA demonstrated that there are ways in which we could make qualitative work speak to the discourses around big data.
What was it like working on this study? Were there any discoveries that you and the team made that you were particularly not expecting?
NR: One thing that came out strongly across all the case studies was that environmental crises actually suppresses women’s agency. This we knew intuitively, but confirmed by the data, the message was clear that climate change is already a crisis, particularly from a gender lens. In all the hotspots, climate change adversely affects women’s agency.
In all the hotspots, climate change adversely affects women’s agency.
The second interesting insight in these hotspots is that household structures seemed to be quite supportive of women’s agency. I had been feeling this for the last 10-15 years. Even in a research a decade ago on intra-household decision making, I had found that with increasing agrarian crises and male migration in rural areas, that men were actually supporting their wives much more in terms of production, income, trust and joint decision making. There was a performance element where men liked to say that they were the decision makers but when we looked at the processes in the field, there was much more cooperation at the household level.
Social norms in terms of gender such as mobility are also changing because of necessity and because of crises. Our analysis strongly showed that it’s really the systemic or the structural factors which are continuing to perpetuate inequality. Both the labour market structures as well as the state structures.
Another interesting finding was that women were using their agency, but to overburden themselves. In addition to their agricultural work and domestic work, they were taking on other very low paid, informal sector activities just to make some extra cash. Agriculture is seasonal so if they have planted, they won’t start getting incomes until the harvest takes place and if the men are away and they are not able to remit regularly, women have to find some way of raising cash locally. This leads to a self-created over-exploitation of their labour.
This over-exploitation was a dilemma for us in terms of conceptualising women’s agency. This is clearly a case where women are taking leadership and decisions but actually we found this has a negative correlation because it’s ending up overworking them rather than empowering. The results are negative health and wellbeing consequences. They were really short of rest, of sleep and were self-exploiting their labour in these very low paid activities.
A final point from our insights is that social capital or community capital is important and I think we’re finding this especially during the pandemic. People are coming together because they have no choice in the absence of state support. When people come together, the state seems to leave it to the people. When social protection is offered, it is done in very individualistic ways and leads to the collapse of social support rather than building a community as well. So there seems to be some kind of cancelation effect that where social capital or community support is strong, the state leaves it to them but where that social capital or community support is not strong, the state may come in and prevents social capital from building because it puts people in competition with each other for limited amounts for state resources; such as competition for jobs. This was an important insight that rather than institutions working together, we find that many are in conflict with each other.

You had an incredible range of partners on this project. What was it like working with this team and what difference did this collaboration make to the project?
NR: It was a fantastic team and a very worthwhile experience. I want to reiterate and acknowledge the support of the funders because when we first started, it was very much up to me to lead. Without building the capacity of young researchers across sites, who are interested in taking gender analysis seriously, we would never have made it to Nature Climate Change.
I felt I was a bit pushy but the donor responded really well. Not many of the other project members were gender experts to start off with but we all learned together and there has been so much of maturing in the group that I personally feel very satisfied. It was a four year project and most of the researchers did not have a gender lens when we started. But now, we have a good set of early career researchers across the institutions and I’m sure that they will continue to think about gender in their work going forward. So for me personally, that has been a really great part of the partnership experience.
Any final remarks?
NR: Just a word for social scientists, and for myself in terms of reflection; perhaps we sometimes take the easy way out. We don’t really publish or try to break into these kinds of journals like Nature or Science. This is a part of the problem.
It’s down to us as social scientists to consider science journals like Nature if we want to be taken seriously.
It was a lot of hard work making this article. It took around three years of planning and work and I think we don’t do it enough for many different reasons. It’s challenging and much more in my comfort zone to write an article to publish in a social science or development studies journal. I also have to say that to get something like this out in a journal like Nature Climate Change for a social scientist couldn’t have happened without the extra funding that we were given.
In social science research projects, we often don’t plan for high impact publications and then without that planning, and without the financial support, it’s very difficult to pull it off. This has been troubling me because when we wrote this article, it got a lot of international media coverage and interviews, including in Time Magazine. I had never experienced that kind of coverage for any of my research and the thing is that some of these insights were not that new. I knew it from my previous research but in a journal like Nature Climate Change, it came out at scale and that proved to be very impactful.
It’s down to us as social scientists to consider science journals like Nature if we want to be taken seriously. I think because we don’t have the resources, it’s outside our comfort zone and we don’t attempt it in the first place. Even in this particular case I was targeting social science publishers with whom I’m much more comfortable until IDRC suggested that this was really innovative and that we should try Nature Climate Change. I was very unsure whether we should go for it so I had a one hour call with Jenn Richler, the editor. I was very diffident about it but she gave a lot of encouragement to make me go for it and to see what comes out of it.
Despite being a very experienced researcher, I needed a lot of hand holding from both the funder and the editor to get this finally out in a journal like Nature Climate Change. In the end though, it was a great experience and it gives us food for thought. We need to plan for it. It won’t happen automatically.
Share this article